Should You Travel to Burma?

ALERT! The following page was written before Cyclone Nargis ripped through the country killing tens of thousands and leaving more than a million homeless. Any kind of travel to Burma has come to a standstill - even for aid workers and journalists. However, in the event the doors reopen, these debates will start again so it's worth understanding the issues surrounding tourism to Burma.

The country is run by a harsh military regime, and international organizations have documented many human rights violations in Burma.

I've been to Burma three times, once as a backpacker and twice as a journalist in the later 1990s. As a reporter I wrote stories on forced labor, HIV/AIDS, minorities and many other topics. Was that the right thing to do? I believe so. Many people read the stories and I hope their awareness about a repressive regime increased as a result. But that was work.

With hindsight, I feel far less comfortable about my backpacking trip, and I'm not certain I would do it again. It's a difficult call, and requires an open mind and constant reevaluation, because there are arguments to both go and stay away.

Arguments in favor of travel to Burma

A number of people support travel to Burma. In fact Lonely Planet guides, by publishing a Burma guidebook, have attracted singular ire and criticism from the boycott Burma lobby and many readers. LP argue that objective information is needed on the country and that, while they do not support the regime, people should be allowed to make up their own minds.

Here are some of the arguments used by those who oppose a travel ban to Burma and believe travel will help the country's people:

• visits by foreigners remind the Burmese that they are not being forgotten by the world community and keeps them informed of the world outside
• travelers and journalists can tell the outside world about human rights violations in Burma and promote action against the military regime
• tourism provides income to ordinary people who work in the tourist industry
• no single leader or luminary can speak for all Burmese, hence calls for boycotts by pro-democracy leader Aung San Suu Kyi should not be seen as necessarily reflecting the will of the majority
• other countries have equally repressive regimes and no one is calling for their boycott
• rather than boycott travel, which benefits the average person, pressure should be brought to bear on the oil and gas companies that are mining the country's resources, using forced labor and paying huge sums to the government for the right to do so
• encouraging greater investment could help open up the country and promote democracy
• boycotts don't work - and they harm citizens more than the government
• democracy won't be created by eliminating freedoms, such as those to travel or share information

Voices for Burma is one group that argues in favor of responsible tourism to Burma.

Arguments against travel to Burma

There appear to be more and louder voices calling for a boycott of Burma and travel ban. The most compelling is that of pro-democracy leader Aung San Suu Kyi, who won the national elections in Burma in 1990 and has since been almost constantly under house arrest. She has said: "Burma will be here for many years, so tell your friends to visit us later. Visiting now is tantamount to condoning the regime."

Calls for bans on travel to Burma have become louder since the military's actions against protesting monks and Burmese citizens in September 2007. Here's what they say about staying away:

• Burma uses forced and child labor to build tourist accommodations and roads
• money spent in the country helps prop up and fund a repressive military regime
• the government uses torture of political prisoners
• discouraging tourism will put economic pressure on the government
• rape is used by the military as a weapon of war against women from minority groups
• the military government believes tourism will help legitimize their regime
• people are systematically displaced to make room for tourism-related projects such as airports
• the democratically elected pro-democracy government (which was never allowed to take power) has asked tourists to stay away and their call should be respected

A good overview of why you should stay away from Burma is presented by the Burma Campaign UK.

Photo: Flickr/Racoles

If you do decide to travel to Burma...

...at least follow a few simple guidelines:

• read as much as you can about Myanmar politics - be highly informed before going
• don't stay at government-run hotels - choose small, locally-owned guesthouses instead
• write to your elected politicians and ask them to take on the issue of Burma
• sign petitions against the government of Myanmar
• try to publish a piece on your trip to Burma when you return, either on your blog or in a newspaper
• try to raise awareness of Burma with your friends, colleagues, or online
• travel independently, not as part of a tour, most of which are linked to the regime

It's not an easy decision, but it is your call.